The following enumeration of surviving New York Central Steam locomotives was printed in the pages of the Central New York Chapter, NRHS Green Block by Richard Palmer. The list is a bit longer than we had previously imagined, but sorry, still no Hudsons!
New York Central System
| #6894 | B-10w 0-6-0 | Alco Pittsburgh 1912 | Connorsville, IN, Whitewater Valley Railroad |
| #6721 | B-11k 0-6-0 | Alco Schenectady 1913 | Utica, NY |
| #999 | C-14a 4-4-0 | West Albany 1893 | Chicago, IL, Museum of Science & Industry |
| #2976 | G-6k 2-8-0 | Alco Brooks 1910 | Fairview, OK |
| #5780 | G-43a 2-8-0 | Alco Brooks 1901 | Chamberlain Lake, ME |
| #8085 | I-80a 4-4-2 | Alco Schenectady 1902 | Dearborn, MI |
| #2933 | L-2D 4-8-2 | Alco Schenectady 1929 | St Louis, MO, National Museum of Transportation |
| #3001 | L-3A 4-8-2 | Alco Schenectady 1940 | Elkhart, IN |
New York Central Subsidiary Roads
| B&A | #39 | 4-4-0 | Boston & Albany 1876 | St Louis, MO, National Museum of Transportation |
| IHB | #15 | 4-6-0 | Alco Schenectady 1897 | Chamberlain Lake, ME |
| P&LE | #9153 | F-102 4-6-0 | Alco Schenectady 1896 | Delson, QUE, Canadian Railway Museum |
| LE&W | #5541 | H-6a 2-8-2 | Baldwin Locomotive Works 1918 | Beech Grove, IN, Indiana Transportation Museum |
| DSI | #5 | 0-4-0T | Vulcan 1923 | Henrietta, NY (no public access) |
New York Central Predecessor Roads
| Dewitt Clinton | (replica) | 0-4-0 | West Point 1831 | Dearborn MI |
| Pioneer | Utica & Schenectady #7 | 4-2-0 | Baldwin 1837 | Chicago IL |
NYCSHS - New York Central System Historical Society 
you are forgetting something the Michigan central 4-6-4 #5212
If you have the details we will add it. The list comes from a list published from an online source several years ago and if there are other locos that have been missed, let us know.
There is a very interesting video that surfaced on Youtube 3 weeks ago entitled, “So we were walking in the woods…” It shows what is supposedly a Niagara Locomotive “Rolling Chassis with Boiler” that was found somewhere in the countryside of Pennsylvania on an abandoned siding. Decide for yourself…I would be interested on what other readers think and their comments on this!